Re: [ALSC-Forum] Monday outreach meeting

[Oscar A. Robles Garay]

Karl,
	Let me try to understand your first point.
	- Are you suggesting that Commercial Interests (is it a correct translation of "business" for you?) should have less preferences than now?
	- The beneficiary group of this preference should be the Non-commercial and individual interests ?
	- What should be the proportion you envisage (50/50, 70/30, other) ?
	- How do you materialize this level of preference (BoD, SO's, other) ?

	Thanks,

Oscar

> <snip>
>
> This raises two points:
>
> First is the duality of ICANN's history.  On one hand "business" (alias
> "stakeholder")  interests on the Internet have been given preferences and
> made the beneficiary of many presumptions (such as that of being
> representative of more than oneself).  Yet on the other hand
> non-commercial and personal/human interests have been excluded entirely or
> placed under onerous limitations.
>
> Personally, I'm rather tired of hearing people being told to ride at the
> rear of the ICANN bus while arbitrary classes of "stakeholders" are
> invited to ride up front.
>
> <snip>
> 		--karl--