RE: [ALSC-Forum] Feedback on Draft Report

[Bruce Young]

Mark Wrote:

>If ALSC is suggesting that only those with a 'contract' with ICANN should
>have a right to ALM, then this does include everyone with an e-mail
address.
>Every e-mail address owner has a contract with the domain name owner, who
in
>turn has a contract with the registrar, who in turn has a contract with
>ICANN. If domain name owners - 'one step' removed from ICANN - are to be
>entitled to ALM, then why not e-mail address owners - who are 'two steps'
>removed, but no less affected by ICANN decisions?

Good logical argument, Mark. But logic and fairness don't seem to be driving
this process.

Bruce Young
Portland, Oregon
byoung651@home.com
http://members.home.net/byoung651/index.html