Re: [ALSC-Forum] Roberts' post

[Eric Dierker]

Thank you for your comments.

You would be better to spend 100 hours or so a week working on these
matters before criticizing those who do.  Mr. Roberts has made his
comments stupid by saying stupid things, if you want to applaud them
feel free.
But I suggest you have not a clue in that you demand positive response
but give none.  And before you go off half caulked ask yourself how many
are on your TFs and the ALSC compared to 30 or so who voted here.

Bria Stysl you represent no one as your position is feeble.

Bria Stysl wrote:

> I support Mike Roberts' comments that people who are
> *sincerely* intersted in creating an Atlarge
> membership/organization should offer constructive
> ideas on how to make this happen. If you don't think
> the ALSC draft is a good plan for achieving this,
> share some ideas to improve it.  *Please* don't waste
> everyone's time chanting "9 seats and votes for all
> humans on earth paid for by ICANN."  Whether you like
> it or not, the only way real progress will be made on
> Atlarge is if the ICANN Board passes a plan, and the
> only way they'll pass a plan is if there's support
> from some of the current ICANN groups. The conclusion
> I draw from this forum is that about 70 people are
> much more interested in hearing themselves talk and
> proclaiming themselves "a consensus" for millions of
> Internet users than they are about *actually making
> Atlarge membership a reality*.  (and to suggest that
> the "straw poll" where 30 people "voted" for 9 seats
> has some legitimacy is really pathetic -- but even
> more pathetic is Jim Wagner/internetnews reference to
> it). I was looking forward to being an Atlarge member
> because I'm actually interested in some of the things
> Icann is doing. If you feel the same way, start acting
> like it -- stop whining and start offering some
> constructive suggestions that have a chance of being
> implemented!
>
> __________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Make a great connection at Yahoo! Personals.
> http://personals.yahoo.com